Wednesday, January 28, 2009

Sore Losers, Anyone?

I continue to be fascinated by American politics. I've just read that the House has passed President Obama's proposed economic stimulus package by nearly a straight party line vote (11 Democrats voted "nay," but this thing was almost straight Red vs. Blue). I'll admit that I know only few details of the actual content of the bill, so I'll keep my commentary brief and to the point. I always think that, but it never happens. Let's see if I can pull it off this time.

The Republican Party continues to impress me with its obstructionism. I don't expect that the two major political parties to ever see eye to eye on anything but a "Flags for Orphans"-style bill, but come on. The President holds a meeting of GOP Congressional leadership, they have a discussion that not even the Republicans would complain about, and then every GOP House member votes against the bill. All I've publicly heard from the Republicans is that the stimulus plan is "wasteful" and that it should include more tax cuts.

That's it.

So here's what I have to ask of the conservative wing of the government - what stimulus package have you assembled? I haven't seen one. I also realize that the Party in control of the Congress decides the voting agenda, but I'm fairly certain that the pundits would have been talking if a reasonable proposal was being drafted by the GOP. All I've heard from the Repubs is that Obama's plan is bad, boo Democrats and their majorities. How about proposing an alternative instead of concentrating on the 2010 election? (Yes, the GOP is already running negative ads against Harry Reid in Nevada)

So, maybe things like re-sodding the National Mall and providing funding for contraceptives don't seem to fit in an economic stimulus (they were removed before the House vote), but at least Obama is proposing an economic stimulus. All the GOP can seem to do is piss and moan about how they don't like it.

Newsflash to the Republicans: If you want to re-establish yourself as a reputable political party on a national level, do something other than whine about how life isn't fair. GOP, you lost big in 2008, largely due to the association with our most recent ex-President, but also due to the pissy campaigning that many of your candidates engaged in (smear tactics and lies). To gain favor with the populous, work with the uber-popular President and compromise, propose ideas that aren't "whatever you guys don't want," and establish an identity that isn't just "whatever you aren't."

Because, GOP, you are gambling. You are just hoping, as Rush Limbaugh keeps blathering, that Obama fails. Because if he does, you will be there to say, "we didn't do it!" If Obama and the Democratic majority do make progress, though, you have no identity except "the ones that didn't do it!" It seems to me that you are gambling with the American people, though. If you have a good idea, propose it and debate it like adults, and don't just play political games when this country's economic viability is at stake.

I look forward to seeing what happens in the coming months.

3 Comments:

At 2:26 PM, Blogger Seymour said...

Republicans have most certainly proposed an alternative stimulus plan.

http://rsc.price.house.gov/UploadedFiles/Econ_Recovery_Act_Highlights_Jan_14_2009.pdf

 
At 9:12 PM, Blogger Justin said...

Well, I'm glad to see someone came up with an original idea. Maybe this is because I can only catch the soundbites during the evening news cycle, but all I ever heard the GOP leadership say was, "tax cuts and cutting spending," which has kind of been what the conservatives have always been about, so it seemed like a tired message. If they had instead said, "we have a distinct plan and here's why it's different," then they would have gotten more attention. Maybe they did say this, and I, like probably many Americans, missed it.

To that I'll add this - how does a litany of tax cuts create jobs? Sen. DeMint the other night proposed scrapping every bit of the stimulus that wasn't a tax cut. That makes no sense to me. Investment in infrastructure and green energy (which ultimately is going to have to be the way of the future, once we run out of oil) sound like a better solution to me. Remember when Bush sent everybody a check? They went straight to the bank and the economy did not improve.

I don't believe the stimulus that Obama proposed is perfect, nor am I a blind zombie to his policies. I disagree with some of the crap that I have heard about in the stimulus, and think it doesn't do enough in other respects. I just think that if we want to see real progress and real political debate, the GOP needs to get on message. I do believe that President Obama is willing to forge bonds with the other side of the aisle. He's smart enough to know that's a good approach. Whether or not he'll be able to do it is another matter, but if he tries, we can't fault him. The GOP has to be willing to reciprocate. Saying that the stimulus should consist of only tax cuts is simply stubbornness and an unwillingness to be creative.

Anyway, thanks for the link. It was a good read and I agree (in principle) with several of those points. But as I said before, we need more than tax cuts.

 
At 3:04 PM, Blogger Seymour said...

Evening news cycle, huh?

So in a half hour show you get about 22 minutes of news. 10 minutes will be devoted to human interest stories. And that's the quality programming: O'Reilly, Hannity, Olbermann, Maddow, and Stewart have been scientifically proven to cause your brain to try to escape from your head.

And my god, some of these internet news sites. The Huffington Post, for example, is owned and operated by a cult-member who hired a spy to stalk the Russert family. Not exactly chock-full of good policy information. Right wing sites are just as bad.

Instead of wasting time with these sources, check out the think tanks. All quality policy analysis, no inane political point scoring, no pettiness. And no subterfuge about an agenda.

You got Brookings (left of center) http://www.brookings.edu/

Cato (libertarian)
http://www.cato.org/

AEI (conservative)
http://www.aei.org/

And Center for American progress (liberal)
http://www.americanprogress.org/

20 minutes a day with these sites instead of TV and blogs and politics will suddenly become less asinine, more intelligent, and just better.

 

Post a Comment

<< Home